221 Prospect Street, Newmarket

$1,399,900
221 Prospect Street

$1,399,900

New
190d
Detached2-Storey

221 Prospect Street, Newmarket

Total Monthly Obligation $6,474

Beds
3
Baths
2
Park
9
Sqft
2000-2500
DOM
190d
Score
15
Yield
3.1%
Cash on Cash
-9.4%
Cap Rate
2.6%
5Y IRR
8.2%
10Y IRR
8.8%
Property Type-Detached
MLS® Number-N13110060
Beds-3
Bathrooms-2
Size-2000-2500 sqft
Lot Size-87.25 × 185 ft
Listed on site-May 11, 2026
Style-2-Storey
Building Type-Detached
Age-100+
Taxes-$5,430.15 (2025)
Parking-9 - None
Basement-Unfinished
Heating-Forced Air (Gas)
Brokerage-RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY
Cooling-Central Air
Laundry-No
Fireplace-No
Pool-None
Facing-East
Exterior-Wood
Roof-Metal
Foundation-Unknown
Sewer-Sewer
Possession-TBD
Neighbourhood-Central Newmarket
Title-Residential Freehold

No agent assigned

Own a piece of Newmarkets history with this enchanting 2-storey home, lovingly cared for and filled with charm at every turn. Sunshine streams through oversized windows, highlighting the original hardwood floors and soaring 9ft ceilings on the main level. The main floor offers the perfect layout and flow, featuring a custom kitchen with a walkout to the backyard, making entertaining effortless, a formal dining room opening up to the living room with oversized pocket doors to close it off if you would like a more intimate dining experience, plus a large bright family room! Every window frames a picturesque view of lush greenery and visiting songbirds, bringing the beauty of nature indoors. With spacious rooms that flow with ease and generously sized bedrooms, this is a home that feels both grand and welcoming. Step outside to discover four dreamy porches, perfect spots to sip your morning coffee, people-watch, or simply soak in the day. The oversized lot is a sanctuary in itself, complete with vibrant gardens, a pear tree, mature trees for shade and privacy, and a cozy fire pit for evenings under the stars. A durable metal roof adds peace of mind, while the extra-long driveway fits up to 9 cars, perfect for gatherings with family and friends. All of this just steps from Fairy Lake and vibrant Main Street, where concerts, skating, the Nokiidaa bike trail, markets, and year-round community fun await. Its a place where history and heart come together, and where every day feels a little more special.

$
$
%
%
$
$
$
(utilities, internet...)
$
%
%

Closing Costs

Mortgage Amount
$1,119,920
Land Transfer Taxes$24,473
Legal Fees (Est.)
$
Total cash required for closing$305,953

Total Monthly Obligation

$6,474/mo
Mortgage $5,647
Monthly Loss $4,988
Principal$1,486
Interest$4,161
Property Tax$453
Home Insurance$125
Variable Costs$250
Returns
Weight: 25%
Cap Rate
2.1%13
Cash-on-Cash
-12.7%0
5-Year IRR
5.6%13
10-Year IRR
7.2%
Returns Index
7.8/ 100
Growth Sentiment
Weight: 20%
%/yr
Score+50
%/yr
Score+50
%
%
Growth Index
50.0/ 100
GradeD
15/ 100
Avoid•Pass

Strategy: Buy & Hold — Weights: CFI 35% · RI 25%
RKI 20% · GI 20%

Assumptions & Inputs
$/mo
%
$
yr
%
Cash Flow
Weight: 35%
Gross Rent
$44,004/yr
NOI
$29,673/yr
Net Cash Flow
-$3,174/mo
Cash Margin
-86.6%0
Cash Flow Index
0.0/ 100
Risk Profile
Weight: 20%
DSCR
0.444
LTV Ratio
80.0%18
Vacancy Buffer
1.5 mo23
Risk Index
15.1/ 100

*This analysis is independently generated NOT provided by TREB or CREA.

Comparables

Properties near 221 Prospect Street

Time

Comparables are calculated within a 3km radius based on properties sold or leased within the past 6 months. This helps you understand the current market value and potential rental yield with high precision.

Data is provided courtesy of PropTx.

The information provided herein must only be used by consumers who have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial or other purpose.

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx or TRREB.

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

The MLS® trademark and MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.

Data last updated within the past 24 hours.