407 Bay Street, Orillia

$1,299,000
407 Bay Street

$1,299,000

Sold Conditional Escape
376d
Detached2-Storey

407 Bay Street, Orillia

Total Monthly Obligation $6,439

Beds
5
Baths
4
Park
6
Sqft
2000-2500
DOM
376d
Score
14
Yield
3.2%
Cash on Cash
-10.8%
Cap Rate
2.3%
5Y IRR
7.1%
10Y IRR
8.0%
Property Type-Detached
MLS® Number-S12515842
Beds-5
Bathrooms-4
Size-2000-2500 sqft
Lot Size-82.98 × 214 ft
Listed on site-Nov 6, 2025
Style-2-Storey
Building Type-Detached
Age-51-99
Taxes-$9,886.82 (2025)
Parking-6 - Attached
Basement-Apartment, Finished with Walk-Out, Full
Heating-Forced Air (Gas)
Brokerage-RE/MAX RIGHT MOVE
Cooling-Central Air
Laundry-No
Fireplace-Fireplace Insert, Natural Gas
Pool-Inground
Facing-West
Exterior-Brick, Vinyl Siding
Roof-Metal
Foundation-Concrete Block
Sewer-Sewer
Possession-TBD
Neighbourhood-Orillia
Title-Residential Freehold

No agent assigned

Welcome to 407 Bay Street, Orillia - located in one of the city's most desirable neighbourhoods. This stunning custom-built 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath, two-storey home showcases exceptional craftsmanship, modern design, and high-end finishes throughout. The main level offers an open-concept dining area and a gorgeous farmhouse-style kitchen featuring a custom oak island, quartz countertops, floating shelves, and a pot filler. The living room boasts a beautiful brick accent wall and a gas fireplace, complemented by an office, 2-piece bath, and a spacious laundry/mudroom with garage access and a walkout to the rear deck. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms, including a bright primary suite with a 3-piece ensuite, plus an additional 4-piece bath. The fully finished lower level features a large recreation room with a gas fireplace, wet bar/kitchenette, walkout to the backyard, two additional bedrooms, a 3-piece bath, fitness area, utility room, and storage. (In-law suite with walk out to pool). The backyard is perfect for family enjoyment, backing onto scenic recreational trails and featuring an in-ground pool with a newer liner and concrete surround. The pool has been professionally winterized. This home has been extensively updated with premium finishes - custom millwork, built-in cabinetry, ship lap details, cedar accents, stunning tile work, upgraded fixtures, and elegant brass hardware. Additional updates include a metal roof, new main and second level windows, composite decking, Regal railing and more. Located across the street from Lake Couchiching, water access via an unopened 66' Bay Street road allowance or Borland St, just minutes to downtown, Couchiching Beach Park, boat launch, shopping and more. A truly remarkable home that must be seen in person to be appreciated.

$
$
%
%
$
$
$
(utilities, internet...)
$
%
%

Closing Costs

Mortgage Amount
$1,039,200
Land Transfer Taxes$22,455
Legal Fees (Est.)
$
Total cash required for closing$283,755

Total Monthly Obligation

$6,439/mo
Mortgage $5,240
Monthly Loss $5,060
Principal$1,379
Interest$3,861
Property Tax$824
Home Insurance$125
Variable Costs$250
Returns
Weight: 25%
Cap Rate
1.8%11
Cash-on-Cash
-14.1%0
5-Year IRR
4.5%10
10-Year IRR
6.4%
Returns Index
6.1/ 100
Growth Sentiment
Weight: 20%
%/yr
Score+50
%/yr
Score+50
%
%
Growth Index
50.0/ 100
GradeD
14/ 100
Avoid•Pass

Strategy: Buy & Hold — Weights: CFI 35% · RI 25%
RKI 20% · GI 20%

Assumptions & Inputs
$/mo
%
$
yr
%
Cash Flow
Weight: 35%
Gross Rent
$42,000/yr
NOI
$23,413/yr
Net Cash Flow
-$3,289/mo
Cash Margin
-94.0%0
Cash Flow Index
0.0/ 100
Risk Profile
Weight: 20%
DSCR
0.373
LTV Ratio
80.0%18
Vacancy Buffer
1.5 mo23
Risk Index
14.8/ 100

*This analysis is independently generated NOT provided by TREB or CREA.

Comparables

Properties near 407 Bay Street

Time

Comparables are calculated within a 3km radius based on properties sold or leased within the past 6 months. This helps you understand the current market value and potential rental yield with high precision.

Data is provided courtesy of PropTx.

The information provided herein must only be used by consumers who have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial or other purpose.

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx or TRREB.

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

The MLS® trademark and MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.

Data last updated within the past 24 hours.