217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake

$4,750,000
217 Butler Street

$4,750,000

Extension
189d
Detached2-Storey

217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake

Total Monthly Obligation $21,924

Beds
5
Baths
6
Park
4
Sqft
5000 +
DOM
189d
Score
13
Yield
1.1%
Cash on Cash
-19.4%
Cap Rate
0.4%
5Y IRR
0.6%
10Y IRR
3.2%
Property Type-Detached
MLS® Number-X13118556
Beds-5
Bathrooms-6
Size-5000 + sqft
Lot Size-138 × 200 ft
Listed on site-May 12, 2026
Style-2-Storey
Building Type-Detached
Taxes-$28,668.06 (2025)
Parking-5 - Built-In
Basement-Unfinished
Heating-Forced Air (Gas)
Brokerage-Johnston & Daniel
Cooling-Central Air
Laundry-No
Fireplace-Natural Gas, Wood
Pool-Inground
Facing-West
Exterior-Wood
Roof-Asphalt Shingle
Foundation-Concrete Block
Sewer-Sewer
Possession-90 Days / TBA
Neighbourhood-101 - Town
Title-Residential Freehold

No agent assigned

Situated in one of Niagara-on-the-Lake's most admired settings, this remarkable property offers a rare combination of scale, character, privacy, and location. Set on nearly an acre at the prominent corner of Queen and Butler, the home captures beautiful outlooks across the golf course (the oldest golf course in Ontario, and one of the oldest in Canada) toward Lake Ontario, all within steps of the shops, restaurants, and charm of Queen Street. The classic white clapboard residence offers more than 5,500 square feet above grade and has been thoughtfully restored, renovated, and expanded to create a warm and inviting home with generous principal spaces. Gas and wood-burning fireplaces add character throughout, while multiple walkouts create an effortless connection to the gardens and outdoor living areas. The property also includes a separate annex, offering excellent flexibility for guests, family, or private work space, with a bedroom, living and dining area, kitchen, and den or second bedroom. The annex was originally converted from a two-car garage, and it could be converted back. Outdoors, the grounds feel like a private retreat. Mature trees, English-style gardens, flagstone patios, a koi pond with bubbler fountain, and a large inground pool create a series of beautiful spaces for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the sun throughout the day. A special offering in one of Niagara's most desirable locations, this property would be equally well suited as an elegant year-round residence or as a memorable getaway for gathering with family and friends. Enjoy all that the Niagara Region has to offer; the Shaw Festival, golf, biking, boating, wineries, and more!

$
$
%
%
$
$
$
(utilities, internet...)
$
%
%

Closing Costs

Mortgage Amount
$3,800,000
Land Transfer Taxes$105,225
Legal Fees (Est.)
$
Total cash required for closing$1,056,725

Total Monthly Obligation

$21,924/mo
Mortgage $19,160
Monthly Loss $16,882
Principal$5,042
Interest$14,118
Property Tax$2,389
Home Insurance$125
Variable Costs$250
Returns
Weight: 25%
Cap Rate
0.3%5
Cash-on-Cash
-21.3%0
5-Year IRR
-0.9%2
10-Year IRR
2.3%
Returns Index
1.9/ 100
Growth Sentiment
Weight: 20%
%/yr
Score+50
%/yr
Score+50
%
%
Growth Index
50.0/ 100
GradeD
13/ 100
Avoid•Pass

Strategy: Buy & Hold — Weights: CFI 35% · RI 25%
RKI 20% · GI 20%

Assumptions & Inputs
$/mo
%
$
yr
%
Cash Flow
Weight: 35%
Gross Rent
$51,000/yr
NOI
$12,732/yr
Net Cash Flow
-$18,099/mo
Cash Margin
-425.9%0
Cash Flow Index
0.0/ 100
Risk Profile
Weight: 20%
DSCR
0.061
LTV Ratio
80.0%18
Vacancy Buffer
0.5 mo12
Risk Index
10.2/ 100

*This analysis is independently generated NOT provided by TREB or CREA.

Comparables

Properties near 217 Butler Street

Time

Comparables are calculated within a 3km radius based on properties sold or leased within the past 6 months. This helps you understand the current market value and potential rental yield with high precision.

Data is provided courtesy of PropTx.

The information provided herein must only be used by consumers who have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial or other purpose.

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx or TRREB.

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

The MLS® trademark and MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.

Data last updated within the past 24 hours.