48 Picnic Island Road, Georgian Bay

$549,900
48 Picnic Island Road

$549,900

Extension
159d
Detached2-Storey

48 Picnic Island Road, Georgian Bay

Total Monthly Obligation $2,757

Beds
4
Baths
2
Park
4
Sqft
1500-2000
DOM
159d
Score
27
Yield
6.5%
Cash on Cash
5.2%
Cap Rate
5.7%
5Y IRR
19.7%
10Y IRR
18.0%
Property Type-Detached
MLS® Number-X13438546
Beds-4
Bathrooms-2
Size-1500-2000 sqft
Lot Size-142.01 × 127 ft
Listed on site-Jun 11, 2026
Style-2-Storey
Building Type-Detached
Taxes-$1,963.81 (2025)
Parking-4 - None
Basement-Partially Finished
Heating-Other (Propane)
Brokerage-Cody Smith Real Estate Brokerage
Cooling-Other
Laundry-No
Fireplace-Yes
Pool-None
Facing-South
Exterior-Brick
Roof-Shingles
Foundation-Block
Sewer-Septic
Possession-FLEXIBLE
Neighbourhood-Baxter
Title-Residential Freehold

No agent assigned

Welcome to this beautifully updated year-round home in the heart of Honey Harbour, offering the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and Muskoka charm. Situated on a spacious property in a desirable location, this well-maintained home features numerous upgrades and renovations, providing peace of mind and modern living for years to come.The bright and inviting interior offers comfortable living spaces, updated finishes, and a functional layout ideal for families, retirees, or those seeking a year-round residence in cottage country.Major updates include 200-amp service with a GenerLink system (2021) capable of powering the home during outages (excluding the oven and hot tub), a propane furnace and hot water tank (2015), propane fireplace (2019), foundation and weeping tile upgrades (2016), sump pump with alarm (2017), and front and rear decks with updated railings (2020). The roof features 35-year architectural shingles (2008), and all main-floor windows were replaced in 2011.The water system was installed in 2007 and has been regularly maintained, including media replacement in 2023 and annual UV bulb servicing, most recently in March 2026. Additional upgrades include a water pump with brass fittings (2018), pressure tank (2019), and a new furnace computer board and heat exchanger installed in March 2026.The property also benefits from extensive electrical improvements, including rewired receptacles and lighting throughout, dedicated breakers for the sump pump and garage fridge/freezer, 15-amp service to the shed and exterior receptacles, and a furnace shut-off switch. The hot tub, installed in 2018, has been updated with a new heater (2023), circulating pump (2024), and pump components (2025).Located just minutes from marinas, Georgian Bay access, local amenities, trails, and year-round outdoor recreation, this move-in-ready property is an excellent opportunity for a permanent residence, weekend retreat, or investment in Muskoka.

$
$
%
%
$
$
$
(utilities, internet...)
$
%
%

Closing Costs

Mortgage Amount
$439,920
Land Transfer Taxes$7,473
Legal Fees (Est.)
$
Total cash required for closing$118,953

Total Monthly Obligation

$2,757/mo
Mortgage $2,218
Monthly Loss $2,173
Principal$584
Interest$1,634
Property Tax$164
Home Insurance$125
Variable Costs$250
Returns
Weight: 25%
Cap Rate
4.7%34
Cash-on-Cash
-0.7%6
5-Year IRR
15.1%72
10-Year IRR
14.6%
Returns Index
38.2/ 100
Growth Sentiment
Weight: 20%
%/yr
Score+50
%/yr
Score+50
%
%
Growth Index
50.0/ 100
GradeD
27/ 100
Avoid•Pass

Strategy: Buy & Hold — Weights: CFI 35% · RI 25%
RKI 20% · GI 20%

Assumptions & Inputs
$/mo
%
$
yr
%
Cash Flow
Weight: 35%
Gross Rent
$35,880/yr
NOI
$25,828/yr
Net Cash Flow
-$66/mo
Cash Margin
-2.2%3
Cash Flow Index
3.1/ 100
Risk Profile
Weight: 20%
DSCR
0.9725
LTV Ratio
80.0%18
Vacancy Buffer
3.4 mo59
Risk Index
33.9/ 100

*This analysis is independently generated NOT provided by TREB or CREA.

Comparables

Properties near 48 Picnic Island Road

Time

Comparables are calculated within a 3km radius based on properties sold or leased within the past 6 months. This helps you understand the current market value and potential rental yield with high precision.

Data is provided courtesy of PropTx.

The information provided herein must only be used by consumers who have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial or other purpose.

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx or TRREB.

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

The MLS® trademark and MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.

Data last updated within the past 24 hours.